Most editorial caption rejections come down to the dateline rather than the description. Shutterstock asks for a specific structure: the city, then the state or country, then an en dash, then the month and day, then a colon and a factual description of what is in the frame. A caption that reorders those elements, lowercases the dateline or substitutes a hyphen for the dash reads as malformed before a reviewer reaches the words.
The format agencies actually ask for
Shutterstock publishes the template directly. Its contributor blog gives the dateline as CITY, STATE/COUNTRY – MONTH DAY: followed by a factual description of the image content, and its editorial guidelines give the same structure with the year appended, as CITY, STATE/COUNTRY – MONTH DAY YEAR:. Either way the shape is identical, and the shape is what gets checked first.
Three details inside that string do most of the damage when they are wrong. The dateline is written in capital letters. The separator before the month and day is an en dash, not a hyphen and not a comma. And a colon closes the dateline before the description begins. None of these are stylistic preferences; they are how a wire-style caption is parsed by the people and the systems reading it.
The description that follows should name the people shown, use an active present-tense verb, and stay factual. Shutterstock asks contributors to pay attention to spelling, formatting, phrasing, capitalisation and punctuation, and notes that the caption must accurately describe the image. A second sentence is allowed where the first one does not fully carry the news angle, and is unnecessary otherwise.
One change is worth knowing if you are working from older instructions or an old template file. Shutterstock's current editorial guidelines state that the date and location no longer need to be repeated in the description portion of the caption. Older advice told contributors to close the first sentence with the date and location, which is why so many captions in circulation still carry both twice.
A malformed caption next to a correctly structured one
The same image captioned two ways. The rejected version uses a hyphen instead of an en dash, a lowercase dateline, a vague description with no named subject, and a passive verb. The corrected version follows the CITY, STATE/COUNTRY – MONTH DAY: structure with an active present-tense description.
Location: when to drop the state or country
Large, internationally recognised cities stand alone in the dateline. Shutterstock's examples of standalone cities include Paris, London and Tokyo, and the list it publishes is explicitly not exhaustive, which is where contributors get stuck. The safe reading is practical rather than legalistic: if a newsroom would not append the country, you do not need to either, and if there is any genuine ambiguity, include it.
The error that actually gets flagged is the inverse of over-caution. Writing a small town without its state or country, or using a district name that only locals would recognise, leaves the caption unverifiable. A reviewer cannot confirm where the picture was taken, and an unverifiable editorial caption is worth nothing to a publisher.
Unknown dates, and what CIRCA is for
Contributors digitising archives hit this immediately. Shutterstock's instruction is to give as much information as is available and to replace the unknown parts with CIRCA, in both the dateline and the description. That is a real option rather than a workaround, and it is far better than the two things people do instead: guessing a plausible date, or leaving the date out and hoping the caption passes anyway. A guessed date in an editorial caption is a factual error, and it is the kind that surfaces after publication.
People you cannot name, and children
Editorial captions are expected to name their subjects, and Shutterstock is specific about sports and celebrity subjects in particular. The rules for everyone else are where contributors improvise, and improvising is what gets the caption returned. For human-interest subjects whose names are not available, the stated convention is to write unidentified rather than to invent a description or leave the subject out of the sentence.
Children carry a stricter standard. Shutterstock asks for the name, the age and the general area of residence. Where that information genuinely cannot be obtained and the photograph is particularly newsworthy, the stated fallback is an unidentified child. That phrasing is not a loophole for street photography of strangers: it exists for genuine news situations, and it sits alongside the ordinary release requirements rather than replacing them.
Length, and the errors reviewers see most
Shutterstock asks contributors to keep captions under its 200-character limit and to make them concise, factual and accurate. That is tighter than it sounds once a dateline, a named subject and a news angle are all in the string, and it is the reason the guidance to stop repeating the date and location in the description matters in practice rather than only on paper. Repetition is usually what pushes a caption over.
Caption errors and what each one needs
Six recurring editorial caption problems, what each one means in review terms and what has to change: dateline casing and punctuation, repeated date and location, guessed dates, unnamed subjects, overlength captions, and editorial captions applied to commercial files.
The opposite error: an editorial caption on a commercial file
This is the error that surprises people, because it punishes a caption written correctly for the wrong track. Adobe Stock rejects commercial content that carries editorial-style captions or titles. The same dateline that Shutterstock requires on an editorial submission is a rejection trigger on an Adobe commercial submission, and contributors who batch-write captions across a shoot often send the editorial style everywhere.
Adobe's own guidance on titles for non-editorial assets is to keep them descriptive and to avoid specific dates, names of people, brand names and event names. Its acceptable example is a plain description of the scene, such as marchers at a gay pride parade, with the searchable concepts carried in keywords like protest, demonstration, march, activist and rally. The unacceptable version is the one that reads like a news caption.
Worth noting alongside this: Adobe states that Editorial Use Only content from individual contributors is generally not accepted at all, with Illustrative Editorial Content as the exception, since its editorial collection comes from outside agencies. So the practical answer for an Adobe submission is usually not to fix the editorial caption but to decide whether the file belongs in that pipeline in the first place.
Keywords are not the caption, and the rules differ
Editorial keywording runs on a different permission set from commercial keywording, and conflating the two produces rejections in both directions. Shutterstock states that unlike commercial images, editorial keywords may include brand names and products, provided they accurately describe the image. Misleading keywords are not allowed, and its own example is not pairing one manufacturer's product with a rival brand name.
Illustrative editorial carries one extra mechanical requirement that is easy to miss in a batch: Shutterstock states that illustrative editorial images must include the keyword illustrative editorial. That is a single keyword, and its absence is the kind of omission that returns an otherwise clean submission.
When a caption must be editorial, and when it must not
The decision is made by the licence, not by the subject matter. A file licensed for editorial use needs a verifiable who, what, when and where, because a publisher has to be able to stand behind it. A file licensed commercially needs a title a buyer can search and nothing that ties the image to a dated, named, branded event, because that is precisely what makes it unusable in an advertisement. The licensing difference between the two tracks is what the caption rules are enforcing.
In practice that means two metadata templates rather than one, applied per batch. The field-by-field differences between editorial and commercial metadata are worth having open while you set those templates up, and the wider question of keeping titles inside each agency's moderation policy covers the rest of the string.
Catching caption errors before delivery, not after
Every error in this article is detectable before the file leaves your machine. A dateline either is or is not in capitals. The separator either is or is not an en dash. The caption either is or is not under the limit. The date either is known, or it is CIRCA, or it is a guess. What makes these errors expensive is not that they are hard to see but that nobody looks at four hundred captions one at a time, so they ship in batches and come back in batches.
That is the part worth automating rather than the writing itself. Rastock AI generates titles, descriptions and keywords from the file, then checks them against each destination's own policy, including banned and mandatory keyword rules, before delivering to 10+ agencies over FTP or SFTP with per-batch status and rollback. Any other marketplace that accepts FTP or SFTP can be added manually as a destination.
It takes no revenue share and claims no ownership of your files, and IPTC, CSV and XML export stay open, so captions you build remain yours in a portable form. The 14-day trial runs without a card, which is enough to put one real editorial batch through the policy check and see what it catches.
What to carry forward
Get the dateline mechanically right, stop repeating the date and location in the description, use CIRCA instead of a guess, identify your subjects or mark them unidentified, and keep the whole thing under the length limit. Then check which track the file is actually on before you apply any of it, because the correct editorial caption is a rejection on a commercial submission, and that single mix-up accounts for more returned files than every punctuation error combined.
Frequently asked questions
What is the correct editorial caption format?
Shutterstock publishes the dateline as CITY, STATE/COUNTRY – MONTH DAY: followed by a factual description, and its editorial guidelines show the same structure with the year included. The dateline is in capital letters, the separator before the date is an en dash rather than a hyphen, and a colon closes the dateline before the description starts.
Do I still need to repeat the date and location in the description?
No. Shutterstock's current editorial guidelines state that the date and location no longer need to be repeated in the description portion of the caption. Older advice told contributors to close the first sentence with both, which is why many captions still carry them twice. Removing the repetition also helps keep the caption inside the length limit.
How long can an editorial caption be?
Shutterstock asks contributors to keep captions under its 200-character limit and to make them concise, factual and accurate. With a dateline, a named subject and a news angle in the same string, that is tighter than it first appears, and repeated information is usually what pushes a caption past the limit.
What do I write when I do not know the date?
Give as much information as is available and replace the unknown parts with CIRCA, in both the dateline and the description. That is Shutterstock's stated instruction for undated material. Guessing a plausible date introduces a factual error into an editorial caption, and omitting the date entirely leaves the caption unverifiable.
How do I caption people whose names I do not have?
For human-interest subjects whose names are not available, the stated convention is to write unidentified. Children carry a stricter standard: name, age and general area of residence, with an unidentified child as the fallback only where that information genuinely cannot be obtained and the photograph is particularly newsworthy. Release requirements still apply separately.
Can I use the same caption style for commercial files?
No, and doing so causes rejections. Adobe Stock rejects commercial content carrying editorial-style captions or titles, and advises keeping non-editorial titles descriptive while avoiding specific dates, people's names, brand names and event names. Adobe also states that Editorial Use Only content from individual contributors is generally not accepted, with Illustrative Editorial Content as the exception.